Home Tech Offsite backup roundup for Mac: Not an easy choice

Offsite backup roundup for Mac: Not an easy choice


By Paul Gauntlett

Offsite backup is the holy grail for those of us who want belt, braces and a pinch of salt to throw over the shoulder. I've tried lots of alternatives and my current choice is Mozy. It's ok for the price but I have encountered unexpected slowdowns and connection problems that other testing proves is nothing to do with my ISP. I was happiest with Jungle Disk but found it relatively expensive for the amount of data I am storing (130GB). Memopal was also a great favourite (a bit like Dropbox but the Mac software is not yet up to the mark). I'm only on a monthly contract with Mozy so could move elsewhere at any time. If I could face three weeks' backing up all over again that is.160px-TheCloud

I kept this informal list of frustrations as I tested each service. Bear in mind, though, that several of these tests were done some time ago and things might have changed. There is a vast list of factors that can influence the speed and efficiency of a backup service, not least of which being your own ISP's upload speed. Typically, upload speeds are a low fraction of the advertised download capability. Most of these services take weeks to do an initial backup of even, say, 35GB: From then on it is considerably faster.

  • Steek: 100GB limit
  • Elephant Drive: 1GB file limit
  • iDrive: Uses a lot of memory
  • Jungle Disk: Too expensive the home use
  • Backblaze: Seems slow but offers zip-file restoration
  • Mozy: Bad past experience, including slowness
  • Safecopy: No way of seeing speed of transfer
  • Novastor: PC only
  • ADrive: 50GB limit and expensive
  • Diino: 100GB limit, clumsy software
  • Spideroak: $10 per month per 100GB
  • Data Deposit Box: $2 per GB per month!
  • Memopal: Allows file search, instant updating (like Dropbox) and download links. Slow, buggy software (seizes up)
  • Carbonite: Uses up huge amounts of CPU, backup sometimes slows to a glacial speed.

So offsite backup is not yet for the faint-hearted, but it does work once you have overcome the initial obstacles. Michael Evans, who uses Carbonite, has had a number of issues and is currently working them out with the help of technical support. He'll report on his findings when (if) the problems get resolved. 


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.