Adobe Enhance with Leica Q2 images: Another look

Our article by John Shingleton on Adobe’s new Enhance feature in Lightroom generated a good discussion on enhancement software in general, including Topaz Gigapixel AI, and the systems which are built into the latest smartphones. Using smartphone cameras, users are often amazed at the detail and ‘pop’ achievable with little effort. I am amazed. Of course, it is easy to be impressed when viewing such a picture on a phone or, even, a tablet. But the limitations of the small sensor do become apparent on large screens or in oversized prints.

John’s article focused on the potential benefits of the digital enhancement of high-resolution shots from, for example, the 47MP Leica Q2. The 28mm fixed lens of the Q2 is an extremely capable optic that produces sharp images that are full of life. But it is a wide-angle lens, and cropping will ultimately play second fiddle to a good-quality long lens mounted on a high-resolution camera.

Leica wants us to crop, though, and even builds in three crop modes to emulate 35mm, 50mm and 75mm angles of view. As discussed before, even the 75mm cropped image from the Q2 is very usable, although the resulting image is down to 6.6 MP. Somehow, it works.

Encouraged by John’s experience, I decided to try the Lightroom Enhance feature on a couple of Q2 scenes, one a landscape (or, rather, riverscape in this instance) and one a street shot in central London. The results were impressive, although mixed.

The river scene

The image below is taken from the west bank of the River Thames as it flows north to south in West London: A perfectly ordinary landscape taken with a wide-angle lens. This is the full frame of 46.7MP. Note the arrow leading to the boxed images of two buildings that are the object of this little experiment.

Below is a simple crop from the larger image, showing the row of houses. The size is down to 0.1MP and it shows it. This is an extreme example and is virtually unusable unless you’d caught Harry & Meghan paddling on the slipway. Then you’d probably be able to flog to a few picture agencies.

But dial in Adobe’s new Enhance feature below, and this tiny crop from a 28mm lens becomes almost viable. It’s certainly a lot better than the untreated version, despite the still tiny pixel count of 0.5MP. Harry & Meghan would be enhanced along with the crop.

It’s still a last-ditch rendering, here entirely for experimental purposes. You will never turn such a massive cropped image into a competitor for real telephoto shots such as the ones below. They are taken from the same spot with the Leica S2 and the Sigma 100-400mm zoom. The first image below is taken at 400mm and slightly cropped to compare directly with the Q2 frame.

The image below is the same S2/400mm crop after enhancement in Lightroom. I see relatively little improvement.

When we delve a little deeper, however, a tiny crop image of the people standing by the slipway is disappointing. It’s certainly not as impressive as the tiny crop from the Q2.

I asked our friend and contributor David Babsky if he could improve on this using software other than Lightroom Enhance. He could. Using Topaz Sharpen AI, Viveza 2, and Topaz Focus AI, he managed a much more presentable crop taken from the original unenhanced image. Thanks, David… Check them side by side below.

Doctoring the image

Now for something a little more common or garden. Here’s a London scene from a corner of Harley Street, home to all the poshest doctors and consultants. The focus is on the street sign. I took this using the 75mm crop feature on the Q2. First, let’s view the full-frame image, all 46.7 MP of it. Just to set the scene…

Below is the 75mm crop, as I saw and composed through the viewfinder. It’s still a presentable image at 6.6 MP. But what if we do a bit of savage cropping to take a look at the definition of the street sign?

As expected, the result is pretty disappointing. The entire frame is, after all, a minute 0.1MP.

Here though, Adobe’s Enhance does make a significant improvement. The enhanced image, below, is 0.5 MP and is pretty impressive considering the distance from the camera and the wide-angle lens used. The improvement in this tiny frame is an indication of the overall improvement to the full-size image and the implications when producing large prints.

Incidentally, all these shots, including those with the S2 and Sigma zoom, were taken hand-held.

Conclusion

In the above examples, crops have been used to help demonstrate the results of the digital enhancement. The primary objective of the Enhance option, however, is to increase the resolution of pictures you are intending to enlarge, perhaps for use on the proverbial bus. Good luck with that.

There are no doubt even more capable digital enhancement applications out there. Still, Adobe’s Enhance does what it says on the tin without the need to stray outside the familiar environment. It’s free to Lightroom subscribers, and it is straightforward to use. Right-click on the image and choose ‘Enhance’ from the menu. It couldn’t be simpler and, I am sure, Enhance will find its use.

We explored the subject in the earlier article, but what do you think of the Adobe Enhance feature in the light of the above examples. Is it something you envisage using; or is it just a gimmick?

A cup of coffee works wonders in supporting Macfilos

Did you know that Macfilos is run by a dedicated team of volunteers? We rely on donations to help pay our running costs. And even the cost of a cup of coffee will do wonders for our energy levels.